Whitianga resident Steve Hart was ‘horrified‘ when, on his return from a trip to Australia, he was forced to drive through Manukau, where – gasp, shock horror – there was rubbish by the side of the motorway and graffiti on buildings. He laments:

“For ourselves, as New Zealanders, we should probably hang our heads a little bit.”

As PC says, what’s with the we, white man?

I have never graffited a building in my life. I have never dumped rubbish by the side of the road, and I often pick up rubbish when I see it on the footpath or in the Botanic Gardens near my house.

Mr Hart’s attempt to make us, as New Zealanders, collectively guilty for rubbish on the side of a motorway is pathetic.

Surprisingly, Dick Quax from the Manukau City Council has at least a bit of sense on this issue:

“[The council has to] to stand up and take responsibility for the look of our city, but individuals have to take some responsibility for the way they act, too.”

In fact there are already organisations like the Manukau Beautification Trust, a private organisation of mostly-volunteers who are doing a very good job of getting rid of rubbish and cleaning up graffiti (they have 20 graffiti removal staff). Ideally, their funding would be by private donation rather than via the council, but they are still a good example of the community tidying itself up.

So pick up the rubbish yourself, Steve, or donate to the people who are already doing it. Yell at taggers when you see them. or call the police if necessary.

But don’t you dare try to make me feel guilty for the actions of others.

Hat tip: Herald on Sunday

These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • ScoopIt
  • Reddit
  • NewsVine
  • del.icio.us
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • SphereIt
  • TailRank

6 Responses to “Guilt? Rubbish.”

What a filthy bunch the Kiwi are. Shame, shame! :)

I kid of course.

In a not so cosmically (or is it simply cosmic? One wonders… The challenge of grammar,) related sense have either of you entertained the recent “Global Warming Swindle” bit? I’d like to see your take on it.

Gravatar

“guilt” is a classification of the limited perceptions of man. Just as “responsibility”. It is perception, which dictates what your mind accepts. You accept that “your actions” are “your responsibility” and therefore attribute that all others should “be responsible”. Perhaps you were taught as a child that lack of action leads to you being a “bad” person, which persuaded you to establish views, opinions, “a backbone”, as others who agree with you would say. It is all perspective. You are simulaneously responsible and not responsible for all which is around you, whether you are aware of it or not. you may pick up rubbish and you may protest on a website, but ignoring that others may not agree is doing no more to progress anything. left wing is the same as right wing. heard of the chaos theory? c’mon luke. incidentally has you brother written anything about “the blanket man” aka Ben Hana of wellington? the discussion of this issue was the last contact i had with him since last year. give my hello, an anonymous hello, anonymous love. semper fidelis. -TheAnomalyInfinite

Gravatar

AnomalyInfinite, I see you a relativist. I believe there is one reality, and within that reality I am a sentient entity currently confined to a single human body, over which I have at least a modicum of control.

I don’t agree that I am “simulaneously responsible and not responsible for all which is around [me]“. I am responsible for my own actions, words, and property, and that is all.

Hence, I am responsible for my own rubbish and graffiti, and that on my own property, and other people are responsible for theirs.

BTW, I fixed the link to your blog. I enjoyed some of your poetry, thanks.

Gravatar

Hi Lili, glad to hear from you again. Chaos theory may suggest that all our actions have unforeseeable effects, but surely what matters in terms of responsibility is what we can foresee, and what we have a choice about. All actions have consequences; we must be conscious of that.

Gravatar

Quax is Manukau City Council.

Gravatar

Thanks Zutroy – I’ve fixed that now.

Gravatar

Something to say?